Under $10

3...2...1...Happy New Year! Help your pet welcome in 2025 with Preppy Puppy's 2025 New Year Martini Cookie! This tasty molasses-based cookie is mad...

🎅 Here comes Santa Paws! Delight your dog this Christmas with this festive Santa Paws Bone Biscuit by Preppy Puppy! It’s flavored with rich molasse...

A donut (or two) never hurt anyone! Sprinkled with seasonal spirit, the Valentine's Love Donut by the Preppy Puppy Bakery is a molasses base recipe...

Sprinkled with seasonal spirit, the Sweetheart Pretzel by the Preppy Puppy Bakery is a molasses base recipe that uses human grade ingredients, so y...

Make Valentine's Day that much sweeter with the Assorted 5.5" Valentine's Large Bone Cookies from Preppy Puppy Bakery! This yummy molasses-based re...

A stout molasses treat your pooch will adore, this delicious Beer Mug cookie from Preppy Puppy is a hand decorated cookie complete with foam. Made ...

Birthdays only come once a year, so make it extra-special with the perfect cute cake! This yummy 4-inch treat is perfect for a single pup's birthda...

Here's to a bow wow wonderful birthday! It's their special day, so give your best friend a Birthday Cupcake by Preppy Puppy Bakery and celebrate! E...

Bliss Cups are drool-worthy confectionary bite-sized delights your pup will love! Made with human grade ingredients, these sweet treats are decorat...

It's their special day, so give your best friend a special treat: the Blue Cupcake by Preppy Puppy Bakery! Made with a rich peanut butter base and ...

Bone-appetite! Keep things simple this Halloween with the Preppy Puppy Bakery's Boo Bone. The designer dog treat is created with a molasses base re...

Preppy Puppy Bakery's Cake Slice Cookies are the yummiest way to celebrate your pup's special day! These delicious birthday treats feature a molass...

Nothing makes a wiggle-butt as excited for the holiday season as Preppy Puppy Bakery's Candy Cane Bars! This festive treat features yummy yogurt ic...

Your pooch will be hooked on these adorable Candy Cane Cookies by Preppy Puppy! These yummy gourmet bakery treats are made with a special molasses-...

Preppy Puppy Bakery's Chirp gourmet dog treats are im-peck-able! Cute as can be, these little guys are made with 100% human-grade ingredients like ...

If only we could all sit around eating Bon Bons all day…but we’ve got too much Christmas shopping to do! Live vicariously through your dog as they ...

Your dog will be delighted as they snack on these delicious peanut butter Bon Bons by Preppy Puppy. Each one is rolled by hand and decorated with a...

Holy cannoli your dog is going to love this holiday treat!  The Christmas Cannoli Dog Treat from Preppy Pupppy Bakery will hit just the spot this s...

Pups everywhere want to stuff their tummies with this festive stocking design! These colorful, yummy gourmet bakery treats are made with a special ...

Fun and colorful PB Bites are the perfect bite-sized delicious noms your best bud will love, bursting with peanuty buttery goodness and made with h...

Bring home some love this Valentine's Day when you present your best canine sweetheart with this darling Conversation Heart Cookie from Preppy Pupp...

Holy cannoli - you won't believe what we've got in our bakery case! The Cranberry Cannoli from the Preppy Puppy Bakery is a molasses based designer...

Summer sunshine is here for your precious pet with this lovely Dolphin Cookie! Indulge in this beach themed summer treat made with tasty peanut but...

Get your pup into the spooky spirit with these creepy Eyeball Patties by Preppy Puppy! These peanut butter-based treats are crafted with human-grad...

Celebrate the season with a Fall Peanut Butter Bite from Preppy Puppy Bakery! Made in the USA with human-grade ingredients, these gourmet treats fe...

Spread some love to your little furkid this year with Preppy Filled Heart cookie. This delicious molasses based recipe made with human grade ingred...

Hut 1, hut 2... Your pup will score a touchdown with this cute football cookie by Preppy Puppy Bakery.   Wheat, Corn and Soy Free Ingredients Rye F...

Festive and fun (and much tastier than snow!), this yummy hand decorated cookie is perfect for holiday treating and makes a great stocking stuffer ...

Funfetti Bites by Preppy Puppy are fun and colorful hand decorated goodies!  Ingredients   Rolled Oats and Peanut Butter - Rolled Oats, Peanut Butt...

Preppy Puppy Bakery Funny Bunnies are colorful and sweet treats your pup will adore!  Hand decorated, each with a cute expression and distinctive f...

Get your game on with these adorable Game Controller Cookies for your pet! Paw-fect for pet parties, birthdays, or even just as a little treat. You...

Mischievous little imps will forget all about tricks when surprised with this spooky Ghost cookie!  Delicious hand decorated nom is perfect for tre...

Celebrate your pet's special day with a yummy, commemorative Gotcha Day Bone Cookie from Preppy Puppy Bakery! Each delicious cookie is made with wh...

A donut (or two) never hurt anyone! Sprinkled with seasonal spirit, the Halloween Donut by the Preppy Puppy Bakery is a molasses base recipe that u...

Celebrate the season with a Happy Fall Y'all Cookie from the Preppy Puppy Bakery! Made in the USA, these gourmet dog treats are baked with mouthwat...

🎅 Ho Ho Ho!  Delight your dog this Christmas with this festive Ho Ho Ho Bone Biscuit by Preppy Puppy! It’s flavored with rich molasses and peanut b...

Comes in assorted fun seasonal colors! Ingredients Rolled Oats and Peanut Butter - Rolled Oats, Unsalted Peanut Butter, Icing (Sugar, Partially Hy...

Your pooch will be hooked on these adorable Holiday Pretzel Cookies by Preppy Puppy! These yummy gourmet bakery treats are made with a special mola...

I Scream...You Scream....We all Scream for Halloween! Surprise your pup with a sweet treat this Halloween with an I Scream Cookie by Preppy Puppy B...

Your pup's the cutest clover in the patch! Help them celebrate St. Patrick's Day with the charming Irish Gnome gourmet dog treat by Preppy Puppy Ba...

Your pooch will be hooked on these adorable Irish Pretzel Cookies by Preppy Puppy! These yummy gourmet bakery treats are made with a special molass...

Present your best friend with these oh-so-delicious Jack O' Ruffles treats from Preppy Puppy. Made with human-grade ingredients, these peanut-butte...

Take your pet on a magical dive under the sea with these colorful Jellyfish Cookies from Preppy Puppy Bakery! You and your precious pooch will feel...

Show your pup some love with Preppy Puppy's Love Gnome gourmet dog treat! Hand-decorated with an adorable pink hat and darling red hearts, this mol...

Your pup is sure to feel special when you bring home this tasty Lucky Bone treat from Preppy Puppy Bakery!  Delicious molasses-flavored cookie is h...

It's happy hour any hour with the Margarita cookie from Preppy Puppy Bakery! This super cute bakery treat will have your dog feeling the buzz of jo...

It's happy hour any hour with the Martini cookie from Preppy Puppy Bakery! This super cute bakery treat will have your dog feeling the buzz of joy ...

Can I get a WOOF WOOF for the Mini Whoopie Pie Dog Treat? Your dog will be all barks and tail waggin when it gets a taste of the Mini Whoopie Pie D...