Under $10

3...2...1...Happy New Year! Help your pet welcome in 2025 with Preppy Puppy's 2025 New Year Martini Cookie! This tasty molasses-based cookie is mad...

Uh oh! Did one of Santa's reindeer get loose? Nope, it's just your fabulous furball decked out in the festive Antler Headband from ZippyPaws! These...

Furry, feathery and filled with catnip - this toy is a feline's dream come true!  Fun winter-bedecked birdie has an intriguing crinkly texture and ...

Nothing makes a wiggle-butt as excited for the holiday season as Preppy Puppy Bakery's Candy Cane Bars! This festive treat features yummy yogurt ic...

Lads and ladies alike just love Earl; he's a charming chicken who dresses to impress no matter what the season. Made of all-natural latex, he makes...

Festive and cheerful, the 9" Christmas Bite Me Bone from PetLou is a fun holiday toy for your favorite doggie! Red and white candy cane striped bon...

Cheerful and bright, the 9" Christmas Bite Me Candy Cane from PetLou is a fun holiday toy for your favorite pooch! Red and white striped candy cane...

If only we could all sit around eating Bon Bons all day…but we’ve got too much Christmas shopping to do! Live vicariously through your dog as they ...

Your dog loves candy canes and it loves bones, so why not combine it in the Christmas Bone Dog Toy? This holiday dog toy is made of a soft, plush m...

Holy cannoli your dog is going to love this holiday treat!  The Christmas Cannoli Dog Treat from Preppy Pupppy Bakery will hit just the spot this s...

This holiday dog house treat is all wrapped up in lights and ready for the season! Delicious, delightful, and lovingly decorated with yogurt and ca...

Cute as a button, PetLou's Christmas EZ Squeaky Hedgehog Dog Toy is ready to help your pup work their wiggles out! Fun knobby ball is covered with ...

Embroidered details, tough stuffing, and a friendly smile are some of the ingredients that make up the Gingerbread Man by Petlou! This cheery fello...

The Ho Ho Ho bone by Petlou is setting the standard for holiday cheer! Embroidered with seasonal spirit, and made of nubby plush good for gripping ...

Celebrate the season with the Multipet Christmas Loofa Dog Toy! Dressed in holiday colors, this long, floppy dog toy is perfect for tossing, tuggin...

These yummy bite-sized Peanut Butter Bites are packed with flavor!  Holiday decorated bites are packaged in a convenient clear box, this collection...

No one is going to miss the nose on this reindeer! With welcoming arms spread wide and mittens and scarf on, this 8" squeaky toy will be a cute add...

There's just something about a happy snowman that melts the heart of people young and old. Put your dog in the holiday spirit with this 8" friend, ...

'Tis the season to be jolly, and the Christmas Tree Meringue Peanut Butter Flavored Treat Cup by Bosco and Roxy's are the holiday treats your pooch...

What dog doesn't love a sweet treat? Now your dog can have it with these perfectly sized Christmas Yogurt Cups by Bosco and Roxys! Come in assorted...

Santa Paws voted these fun elves as the cutest and tastiest cookies you'll find outside the North Pole!  Festive elf cookies are hand decorated and...

Get ready for some festive fun with the Eli Elf Ruff-Tex® Latex Ball Dog Toy! This adorable elf-shaped toy is perfect for tossing, chewing, and all...

Adorably warm and stylish, the festive Fairisle Hat from Huxley & Kent will keep your favorite pooch warm this winter season. Classic pattern i...

Festive and fun (and much tastier than snow!), this yummy hand decorated cookie is perfect for holiday treating and makes a great stocking stuffer ...

The holidays are coming and you need a special tree for your best buddy. Bosco and Roxy's Happy Tree is a tasty and festive treat your pet will lov...

Set the table with a dinner mat for your small fur babies with the HugSmart Happy Woofmas Dog Toy! This festive toy is complete with an adorable to...

Treat your cat to holiday cheer with the KONG Holiday Crackles Santa Kitty Cat Toy! This adorable Santa-themed kitty toy is packed with crinkly cra...

For the good boys and girls on your list, these festive and yummy treats are packaged in a colorful holiday box and ready for gifting.  Collection ...

Henrietta is a charismatic chicken with sassy style. Everyone loves her bold holiday outfit! Made of all-natural latex, she makes an impressive squ...

These simply festive pillow-shaped toys are the perfect way to indulge kitty's sweet tooth for catnip! Holiday print 2.5" squares are stuffed with ...

These limited edition holiday treats are exactly what your pup needs after we all got frustrated and knocked down our gingerbread house. Who needs ...

Comes in assorted fun seasonal colors! Ingredients Rolled Oats and Peanut Butter - Rolled Oats, Unsalted Peanut Butter, Icing (Sugar, Partially Hy...

KONG'S Holiday Pull-A-Partz Luvs cat toy is built for festive fun! This interactive toy stimulates your kitty's natural hunting instincts as they p...

Festive, fun, and, of course, delicious, the Holiday Rudolph Bag from Two Bostons is the tastiest gift your pooch will get this season! Each bag of...

Don't forget to check off the good boys and girls on your list with the Holiday Santa Gnome Bag this holiday season! Festive and oh-so-tasty, these...

Thanks to Plato's Holiday Small Bites Chicken Gingerbread Treats, you can share the warm taste of a seasonal favorite with your pup. These deliciou...

A bag of delightfully delicious noms, just for your good dog!  Cute Snowman and Peanut Butter  cookies come in a festive bag, ready for gifting.  Y...

These simply festive candy-shaped toys are the perfect way to indulge kitty's sweet tooth for catnip! Stix are stuffed with farm fresh catnip and a...

Bring festive playtime to life with the KONG Holiday Teaser Loopz Catnip Wand! This interactive wand toy features colorful holiday-themed spirals t...

This polar bear teddy is one of the cutest cookies we’ve ever laid eyes on. This crunchy sweet potato treat with yogurt coating is just as deliciou...

The Jester Collar from Fuzzyard is the paw-fect holiday accessory for your four-legged friend! Perfect for photo ops and holiday parties, this comf...

Put a little jingle on your pup and enjoy the festivities with the Jingle Bell Collar by FuzzYard! This classic red and furry white trim collar wit...

Let your cat join in the festive fun with the FuzzYard Jolly Old St. Pickl-ous Cat Toy! This quirky pickle, complete with a jolly Santa hat, is pac...

The stockings were hung by the chimney with care, in hopes that St. Pickl-ous would soon be there...  The FuzzYard Jolly Old St. Pickl-ous Dog Toy ...

Adorable and festive, the Kittybelles Mittens for Kittens toy from Lulubelles is a fun and crinkly holiday toy filled with organic catnip. Soft plu...

Oh, Snap! Kittybelles Gingerbread Man seems to have lost a leg! Not to worry, your kitty will still love this whimsical holiday toy filled with org...

Remember Lamb Chop? Even if your dog is too young to recall, he'll still enjoy this soft and squeaky toy with the festive Santa hat. Toy measures: ...

Delight your favorite feline with Huxley and Kent's Lit Donut & Peppermint Candy cat toys! This adorable and festive duo includes a plush donut...